How Do I Order Baseball Trading Pins?

Ordering custom baseball trading pins from Lapel Pins Plus is simple. Our trading pins are built with the same die-struck soft enamel construction used for military challenge coins — giving your team a pin that stands out during trades and lasts as a keepsake for years.

How to Order

1. Visit Our Baseball Trading Pins Page

Head to our baseball trading pins page and use the quote configurator to select your size, quantity, and customization options.

2. Choose Your Design Elements

Every baseball trading pin is fully custom. Popular design elements include:

  • Team name and mascot
  • Player numbers or team roster
  • Tournament name and year
  • Team colors and logos

3. Add Upgrades

Make your pin the one every player wants to trade for. Available upgrades include:

  • Spinners — rotating metal elements that add motion and fun
  • Danglers — hanging charms that swing from the main pin
  • Glitter enamel — sparkle-infused color fills that catch the light
  • LED/blinkers — light-up elements for maximum visibility

4. Submit and Get Your Free Quote

Submit your configuration along with any artwork or ideas. Our designers will create production-ready artwork at no charge and send you a proof to approve before manufacturing begins.

What's Included

  • Die-struck soft enamel construction with raised metal borders
  • Up to 7 colors at no extra charge
  • Free artwork — send us your logo, sketch, or just a description
  • Free priority air shipping to anywhere in the US
  • Production time: 7–10 business days after proof approval

Planning for Tournament Season

Trading pins are a tradition at Cooperstown, Little League tournaments, travel ball events, and rec league championships. We recommend ordering at least 3–4 weeks before your event to allow time for quotes, proof approval, production, and shipping.

If you're on a tighter timeline, let us know — we'll do everything we can to meet your deadline.

Why Lapel Pins Plus?

Our baseball trading pins are manufactured to the same standard as our premium soft enamel lapel pins, not the thin stamped pins you get from budget suppliers. Teams have full creative control, and the finished product is something players are proud to trade and collect.

Start your free quote at our baseball trading pins page.